Amway wins a big round on Satanism

Dismissal of firm from P&G lawsuit is upheld

Detroit Free Press/January 8, 2003
By John Gallagher

Ada-based Amway Corp. has won an important round in a legal struggle with Procter & Gamble over accusations that Amway spread false rumors that P&G was involved with Satanism.

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the 10th Circuit in Denver upheld this week a lower court's dismissal of Amway as a defendant in P&G's lawsuit. P&G, a leading consumer products producer, maintains that Amway and its distributors, which sell competing products, spread such rumors to hurt P&G's sales and thus benefit Amway.

Amway, now a wholly owned subsidiary of Alticor Inc., has long denied spreading any such rumors. It dismisses the alleged Satanism link as nothing more than a "persistent urban legend."

Devil-worship rumors began linking P&G's former crescent-shaped logo depicting a bearded man on the moon and stars to Satanism in the late 1970s.

The supposed satanic connection was further fueled by a rumor that the company's president had promoted devil-worshipping on a Phil Donahue show. No such show was ever taped.

The Monday ruling, by a unanimous three-judge panel, upheld a 2001 decision by a Utah federal district court dismissing Amway as a defendant in the case.

In a 25-page opinion, Judge Robert Henry criticized P&G, saying it had "unremittingly sought to relitigate and reassert previously adjudicated issues."

The court rejected each of the five issues P&G had appealed and chastised P&G several times for what it called vague and confusing legal arguments.

The judge said in his conclusion: "Throughout this and its related protracted and duplicative litigation, P&G has tried to evade the law of the case doctrine, and has squandered scarce judicial resources."

Said Michael Mohr, Amway's general counsel: "We are proud but not surprised that Amway has been completely vindicated in this ridiculous case. We never spread the rumor -- in fact, we spent years helping P&G fight it."

P&G spokeswoman Gretchen Muchnick said the company was disappointed with the decision. But she noted that litigation is still under way in Texas in which P&G is seeking damages from several Amway distributors and Amway itself for allegedly spreading the rumors. And, she said, "Since these lawsuits were filed, the rumors have essentially stopped."

To see more documents/articles regarding this group/organization/subject click here.


Educational DVDs and Videos